The elements of chance and improvisation mean that no two performances of Indeterminacy will ever be the same – each time we are witnessing something perfectly unique and strange. Featuring a variety of unusual instruments, and a highly unorthodox use of children’s toys, Alan Tomlinson, Stewart Lee, Tania Chen and Steve Beresford experiment with the elements of chance in performance, and they blur the lines between contemporary concert and art – as well as between absurdity and high seriousness.
Contemporary pianists Chen and Beresford opened the evening with dual piano improvisations, laying the groundwork for John Cage with their freeform, playful experiments. Chen plucked at the strings of the open piano; Beresford knocked on silenced keys and clicked the music stand; at times tentatively leaving each other space, and at others more aggressively assaulting the audience with tumultuous amelodic storms.
Next, Alan Tomlinson introduced his interpretation of Cage’s Solo for Sliding Trombone with a brief explanation of some of the score’s playful-yet-inevitably-frustrating difficulties. Cage’s instructions are vague enough to allow the piece to be mostly improvised – the score is provided in “small, medium and large” notes, the dynamics and durations of which are left up to the performer. The piece consists of a range of short, mostly one-note bursts of sound – Tomlinson described this as “a series of small events” – none of which are of the same quality.
What Tomlinson clearly relishes in this piece is the chance to seriously explore the range of the trombone’s sound, and indeed he does just about everything you can imagine with a plastic cup and two or three mutes.
He picks up a tin-foil pie pan; he teases us a bit by reaching for a plastic cup – but no, he replaces it once again; he leaves achingly long pauses between notes; he spins in a circle; and finishes the whole thing by gurgling into his instrument before defiantly releasing the spit valve on the floor. It’s cheeky, it’s avant-garde, and it sounds like a seriously odd jumble of noise-events, but Tomlinson’s skill and confidence in presenting such a difficult piece to us shone through.
John Cage’s Indeterminacy – the evening’s main event – plays with similar themes of chance and improvisation. The piece was originally comprised of 90 cards on which 90 short stories or anecdotes were written. In this performance, comedian Stewart Lee (giving a rather sober, straight-faced reading) has shuffled through the deck and selected 40 of these cards. The stories he tells – another “series of small events” – range from trivial accounts of Cage’s acquaintances to very funny memories of mushroom exhibitions and strange parables about monks. Some are more serious – discussing freedom, modern music, the meaning of life – but by contrast anecdotes on the homely pigeon and grandmothers are all the more funny and absurd.
These stories are also of wildly varying length – and Lee deftly manages to adjust his reading speed (with hilarious results) to fit each card into the space of one minute, while maintaining a discomforting monotone voice devoid of dynamic variation or expression. The whole performance is totally absurd and disorienting – and the seriousness with which Lee reads, with which Chen and Beresford carefully pick up a child’s noisemaker, comes across as extremely comical on more than one occasion.
Sound and text are in tension throughout – Chen and Beresford perform improvisations on a truly unusual range of instruments and non-instruments, occasionally completely overpowering Lee’s reading. We are told that these sounds are meant to bear no relation to the meaning of the text – which partially explains the incredibly incongruous set of soundmakers, including toy pianos, flashing guns, rubber balls in a barrel, graters, and a music box playing the Pink Panther theme – yet Cage’s text does give us little knowing winks of meaning now and then, commenting on sound drowning out speech, on the nature of understanding, and recalling moments of incongruity in which he played two different pieces at once, by accident, with his friend David Tudor.
So – what was Indeterminacy after all? Was it a piece of theatre, or was it just a very avant-garde concert? Was it a rare window on the inner lives of artists engaged in a strange, private ritual of creativity? And, most importantly, can you ever really take such avant-garde performance seriously? Cage, and the evening’s performers, give us no determinate answers – but they poke at us, playfully, with strange new sounds that left me with the undefined buzz of experiment.
James Dellingpole, Daily Telegraph
James Dellingpole, Daily Telegraph
Tres Ryan, Twitter
Tres Ryan, Twitter
98rosjon, Twitter
98rosjon, Twitter
Peter Fears, Twitter
Peter Fears, Twitter
Tin Frog, Twitter
Tin Frog, Twitter
Lenny Darksphere, Twitter
Lenny Darksphere, Twitter
Genghis McKahn, Guardian.co.uk
Genghis McKahn, Guardian.co.uk
Meanstreetelite, Peoplesrepublicofcork
Meanstreetelite, Peoplesrepublicofcork
General Lurko 36, Guardian.co.uk
General Lurko 36, Guardian.co.uk
Funday’schild, youtube.
Funday’schild, youtube.
Contrapuntal, Twitter
Contrapuntal, Twitter
Cabluigi, Guardian.co.uk
Cabluigi, Guardian.co.uk
Alwyn, Digiguide.tv
Alwyn, Digiguide.tv
Iain, eatenbymissionaries
Iain, eatenbymissionaries
Karen Laidlaw, Edfringe. com.
Karen Laidlaw, Edfringe. com.
Jackmumf, Twitter
Jackmumf, Twitter
Patrick Kavanagh, Guardian.co.uk
Patrick Kavanagh, Guardian.co.uk
Bosco239, youtube
Bosco239, youtube
Sam Rooney, Youtube
Sam Rooney, Youtube
Rowing Rob, Guardian.co.uk
Rowing Rob, Guardian.co.uk
NevW47479, UKTV.co.uk
NevW47479, UKTV.co.uk
Chez, Chortle.com
Chez, Chortle.com
Neva2busy, dontstartmeoff.com
Neva2busy, dontstartmeoff.com
Joycey, readytogo.net
Joycey, readytogo.net
Anon, westhamonline.com
Anon, westhamonline.com
Cyberbloke, Twitter
Cyberbloke, Twitter
Sidsings000, Youtube
Sidsings000, Youtube
Lancethrustworthy, Youtube
Lancethrustworthy, Youtube
Peter Ould, Youtube
Peter Ould, Youtube
Rubyshoes, Twitter
Rubyshoes, Twitter
Johnny Kitkat, dontstartmeoff.com
Johnny Kitkat, dontstartmeoff.com
GRTak, finalgear.com
GRTak, finalgear.com
Slothy Matt, Twitter
Slothy Matt, Twitter
Dahoum, Guardian.co.uk
Dahoum, Guardian.co.uk
Idrie, Youtube
Idrie, Youtube
Microcuts 22, Twitter
Microcuts 22, Twitter
Fairy Pingu, Twitter
Fairy Pingu, Twitter
Sweeping Curves, Twitter
Sweeping Curves, Twitter
Whoiscuriousgeorge, Youtube
Whoiscuriousgeorge, Youtube
Len Firewood, Twitter
Len Firewood, Twitter
Anamatronix, Youtube
Anamatronix, Youtube
Rudeness, Youtube
Rudeness, Youtube
FBC, finalgear.com
FBC, finalgear.com
Visualiser1, Twitter
Visualiser1, Twitter
Frankie Boyle, Comedian
Frankie Boyle, Comedian
Anonymous, don'tstartmeoff.com
Anonymous, don'tstartmeoff.com
Al Murray, Comedian
Al Murray, Comedian
12dgdgdgdgdgdg, Youtube
12dgdgdgdgdgdg, Youtube
Guest1001, Youtube
Guest1001, Youtube
Fowkes81, Twitter
Fowkes81, Twitter
World Without End, Twitter
World Without End, Twitter
Gabrielle, Chortle.com
Gabrielle, Chortle.com
Yukio Mishima, dontstartmeoff.com
Yukio Mishima, dontstartmeoff.com
Danazawa, Youtube
Danazawa, Youtube
Mrdavisn01, Twitter
Mrdavisn01, Twitter
Tweeter Kyriakou, Twitter
Tweeter Kyriakou, Twitter
Leach Juice, Twitter
Leach Juice, Twitter
Kozzy06, Youtube
Kozzy06, Youtube
Bobby Bhoy, Twitter
Bobby Bhoy, Twitter
Lee Mack, Mack The Life, 2012
Lee Mack, Mack The Life, 2012
Richard Herring, Comedian
Richard Herring, Comedian
Jamespearse, Twitter
Jamespearse, Twitter
Maninabananasuit, Guardian.co.uk
Maninabananasuit, Guardian.co.uk
Anonymous, The Northfield Patriot
Anonymous, The Northfield Patriot
Emilyistrendy, Youtube
Emilyistrendy, Youtube
A D Ward, Twitter
A D Ward, Twitter
Horatio Melvin, Twitter
Horatio Melvin, Twitter
Aiden Hearn, Twitter
Aiden Hearn, Twitter
Brighton Argus
Brighton Argus
Pnethor, pne-online.com
Pnethor, pne-online.com
Guest, Dontstartmeoff.com
Guest, Dontstartmeoff.com
Foxfoxton, Youtube
Foxfoxton, Youtube
Henry Howard Fun, Twitter
Henry Howard Fun, Twitter
Liam Travitt, Twitter
Liam Travitt, Twitter
Hiewy, Youtube
Hiewy, Youtube
Stuart, Chortle
Stuart, Chortle
Stokeylitfest, Twitter
Stokeylitfest, Twitter
Birmingham Sunday Mercury
Birmingham Sunday Mercury
Keilloh, Twitter
Keilloh, Twitter
Alex Quarmby, Edfringe.com
Alex Quarmby, Edfringe.com
Coxy, Dontstartmeoff.com
Coxy, Dontstartmeoff.com
Dominic Cavendish, Daily Telegraph
Dominic Cavendish, Daily Telegraph
Tokyofist, Youtube
Tokyofist, Youtube
Borathigh5, Youtube
Borathigh5, Youtube
Clampdown59, Twitter.
Clampdown59, Twitter.
Zombie Hamster, Twitter
Zombie Hamster, Twitter
Tweeterkiryakou, Twitter
Tweeterkiryakou, Twitter
Carcrazychica, Youtube
Carcrazychica, Youtube
Meninblack, Twitter
Meninblack, Twitter
Gwaites, Digitalspy
Gwaites, Digitalspy
Cojones2, Guardian.co.uk
Cojones2, Guardian.co.uk
Joe, Independent.co.uk
Joe, Independent.co.uk
Aaron, comedy.co.uk
Aaron, comedy.co.uk
Robert Gavin, Twitter
Robert Gavin, Twitter
Gmanthedemon, bbc.co.uk
Gmanthedemon, bbc.co.uk
Shane, Beverley, Dailymail.co.uk
Shane, Beverley, Dailymail.co.uk
Dave Wilson, Chortle.com
Dave Wilson, Chortle.com
Shit Crit, Twitter
Shit Crit, Twitter
Z-factor, Twitter.
Z-factor, Twitter.
Wharto15, Twitter
Wharto15, Twitter
Deepbass, Guardian.co.uk
Deepbass, Guardian.co.uk
Mearecate, Youtube
Mearecate, Youtube
Dick Socrates, Twitter
Dick Socrates, Twitter
BBC iPlayer edition of discussion of Stewart Lee on A Good Read
BBC iPlayer edition of discussion of Stewart Lee on A Good Read
Anon, BBC Complaints Log
Anon, BBC Complaints Log
Lucinda Locketts, Twitter
Lucinda Locketts, Twitter
Syhr, breakbeat.co.uk
Syhr, breakbeat.co.uk
Mini-x2, readytogo.net
Mini-x2, readytogo.net
Anon, dontstartmeoff.com
Anon, dontstartmeoff.com
Neolab, Guardian.co.uk
Neolab, Guardian.co.uk
DVDhth's grandparents, Twitter
DVDhth's grandparents, Twitter
Dominic Cavendish, Telegraph
Dominic Cavendish, Telegraph
Secretdeveloper, Youtube
Secretdeveloper, Youtube
Someoneyoudon'tknow, Chortle.com
Someoneyoudon'tknow, Chortle.com
Peter Ould, Twitter
Peter Ould, Twitter
Carla, St Albans, Dailymail.co.uk
Carla, St Albans, Dailymail.co.uk
Lents, redandwhitekop.com
Lents, redandwhitekop.com
Pudabaya, Twitter
Pudabaya, Twitter
Esme Folley, Actress, cellist, Twitter
Esme Folley, Actress, cellist, Twitter
Mpf1947, Youtube
Mpf1947, Youtube
Joskins, Leeds Music Forum
Joskins, Leeds Music Forum
John Robins, Comedian
John Robins, Comedian
Ishamayura Byrd, Twitter
Ishamayura Byrd, Twitter
Spanner, dontstartmeoff.com
Spanner, dontstartmeoff.com
Pudabaya, beexcellenttoeachother.com
Pudabaya, beexcellenttoeachother.com
Etienne, Chortle.com
Etienne, Chortle.com
Nicetime, Guardian.co.uk
Nicetime, Guardian.co.uk
Pirate Crocodile, Twitter
Pirate Crocodile, Twitter
Brendon, Vauxhallownersnetwork.co.uk
Brendon, Vauxhallownersnetwork.co.uk