This month’s in-depth investigation into the state of British music journalism concerns opposite attitudes towards the oft-derided debating forum that is the online comment community
The idea of giving music journalists prizes is obviously ridiculous. Is going to gigs for free with an outside chance of standing next to Everett True not reward enough for these people? The one context in which some measure of formal acclaim might be constructive, however, would be in the category of “best sentence”. From Lester Bangs and Paul Morley to Chuck Eddy and Kodwo Eshun (before he took the silver shillings of academe and the international art world), the true giants of rock writing have traditionally distinguished themselves by their ability to compress an extraordinary amount of cultural elucidation into the interval between a capital letter and a full stop.
Stewart Lee’s recent declaration of occult war on his rival 90s polymath Damon Albarn contained at least two worthy candidates for July 2011’s inaugural Ian Penman Memorial Sentence of the Month award (sponsored by Tipp-Ex. “But imagine Bowie instead as a cunning lichen, an adaptive tuber or a semi-sentient mould, endlessly reshaping himself in search of the moisture of acclaim, and it is easy to understand him” is my favourite. Although the alarming if possibly fallacious suggestion that “Louise Weeners of the Sleeper [sic] is planning a lighthearted chick-lit novel about Ithell Colquhoun and her magic goose” runs it close.
As those Comment is Free respondents who scathingly noted Lee’s in fact humorously intended misidentification of the Witchfinder General as “Mary Hopkin” may finally be realising, the late-night BBC2 comedian’s mis-spelling of the name of the second-rank-Britpop-siren-turned-persistent-literary-wannabe Louise Wener is probably not an accident. Professional music journalists are not generally encouraged to make deliberate mistakes (although there is the odd one who tries to get away with it every now and again out of sheer perversity) but Lee’s unique position – suspended between celebrity super-fan, benevolent critical authority and satirical observer of the absurdities of pop discourse – allows him latitude in this area.
Of course, Stewart Lee would be unlikely to get people’s names wrong for comic effect in one of the scrupulously scholarly Sunday Times record reviews that have established him as News International’s leading authority on extemporised instrumentals. And his recent almost overnight transition from self-styled surly sixth-form common-room existentialist to mini Meltdown-curating pillar of the contemporary cultural establishment does pose an intriguing threat to the strict separation of powers between serious-minded advocate of Dutch free improvisation and wilfully divisive poker of sticks into the hive mind that has served him so well thus far. But why shouldn’t Lee continue to combine the unabashed idealism of the Corinthian enthusiast with the cold-eyed ruthlessness of the professional comedic assassin? Surely it was just such a variety of potentialities that the poet Walt Whitman had in mind when he pioneered the notion of an individual containing multitudes?
The Word message-board is not necessarily the first place you’d look to see Whitman’s dreams of diverse human possibility fulfilled. But the revelation in the magazine’s 174th podcast that the “only active thing” one-time NME sentence-overlord Danny Baker (and a joke Baker once made about the Raincoats in a live review is still regularly cited as one of the finest achievements in all English literature) managed to do in the course of his recent serious illness was make mischievous contributions to that oft-derided debating forum has certainly done wonders for the status of the pseudonymous online contributor.
One participant in the ensuing quest to unmask Baker’s alter ego (which proved mercifully inconclusive, as a positive ID would have spoiled the fun) posited an intriguing idea. Perhaps the prevailing harshness of message-board debate might be mitigated if prior to pressing “submit” on another scourging denunciation of a rival thinker’s ancestral lineage or all-round mental fitness, online contributors could “consider that the person posting might be in complicated circs”. My suggestion is that we symbolically set aside any lingering unease prompted by the use of the abbreviation “circs”, name this commendably humane initiative “Baker’s Law”, and see if it helps us impose some discipline on what Jaron Lanier has resonantly termed our “inner troll”.
Stewart Lee’s alternative to the former Six O’Clock Show presenter’s “If you’re not well enough to beat them, join them” strategy – gathering together all the most savage personal attacks on him in one place in the hope of prompting a collective recalibration of Gordon Brown’s moral compass – certainly seems to have had the opposite effect to the one intended. So rather than dropping a carcass into the shark-tank, why not fit all the sharks with Danny Baker masks and see if that stops them biting each others’ (and, indeed, our) faces?
After all, it can only be a matter of time before the process of anguished self-examination set in train by the News of the World phone-hacking scandal spreads out from the antedeluvian print media into the broader interactive hinterland. And as the decorous new era of content mutualisation dawns, perhaps a day will one day come when 21st-century opinion-formers no longer need to view a violently hostile reception from the online comment community as a badge of honour. In the meantime, Lee’s determination to continue biting the hand that feeds him – whether that hand is his own or Michael McIntyre’s – will continue to be an inspiration to those who believe rigorous self-regulation can still transcend the discipline of the virtual lynch-mob.
Yukio Mishima, dontstartmeoff.com
Yukio Mishima, dontstartmeoff.com
Lee Mack, Mack The Life, 2012
Lee Mack, Mack The Life, 2012
Genghis McKahn, Guardian.co.uk
Genghis McKahn, Guardian.co.uk
Someoneyoudon'tknow, Chortle.com
Someoneyoudon'tknow, Chortle.com
Etienne, Chortle.com
Etienne, Chortle.com
John Robins, Comedian
John Robins, Comedian
Tin Frog, Twitter
Tin Frog, Twitter
Emilyistrendy, Youtube
Emilyistrendy, Youtube
Robert Gavin, Twitter
Robert Gavin, Twitter
Al Murray, Comedian
Al Murray, Comedian
Tweeter Kyriakou, Twitter
Tweeter Kyriakou, Twitter
Pnethor, pne-online.com
Pnethor, pne-online.com
Rubyshoes, Twitter
Rubyshoes, Twitter
Stuart, Chortle
Stuart, Chortle
DVDhth's grandparents, Twitter
DVDhth's grandparents, Twitter
Carcrazychica, Youtube
Carcrazychica, Youtube
Jackmumf, Twitter
Jackmumf, Twitter
Joycey, readytogo.net
Joycey, readytogo.net
Syhr, breakbeat.co.uk
Syhr, breakbeat.co.uk
Dick Socrates, Twitter
Dick Socrates, Twitter
Brighton Argus
Brighton Argus
Rudeness, Youtube
Rudeness, Youtube
Birmingham Sunday Mercury
Birmingham Sunday Mercury
Rowing Rob, Guardian.co.uk
Rowing Rob, Guardian.co.uk
Brendon, Vauxhallownersnetwork.co.uk
Brendon, Vauxhallownersnetwork.co.uk
Chez, Chortle.com
Chez, Chortle.com
Shane, Beverley, Dailymail.co.uk
Shane, Beverley, Dailymail.co.uk
Lents, redandwhitekop.com
Lents, redandwhitekop.com
Patrick Kavanagh, Guardian.co.uk
Patrick Kavanagh, Guardian.co.uk
Alex Quarmby, Edfringe.com
Alex Quarmby, Edfringe.com
Aaron, comedy.co.uk
Aaron, comedy.co.uk
Slothy Matt, Twitter
Slothy Matt, Twitter
Mearecate, Youtube
Mearecate, Youtube
Foxfoxton, Youtube
Foxfoxton, Youtube
Neva2busy, dontstartmeoff.com
Neva2busy, dontstartmeoff.com
Karen Laidlaw, Edfringe. com.
Karen Laidlaw, Edfringe. com.
Lucinda Locketts, Twitter
Lucinda Locketts, Twitter
Leach Juice, Twitter
Leach Juice, Twitter
Gmanthedemon, bbc.co.uk
Gmanthedemon, bbc.co.uk
James Dellingpole, Daily Telegraph
James Dellingpole, Daily Telegraph
Gwaites, Digitalspy
Gwaites, Digitalspy
A D Ward, Twitter
A D Ward, Twitter
Joe, Independent.co.uk
Joe, Independent.co.uk
Anonymous, The Northfield Patriot
Anonymous, The Northfield Patriot
Contrapuntal, Twitter
Contrapuntal, Twitter
Nicetime, Guardian.co.uk
Nicetime, Guardian.co.uk
Whoiscuriousgeorge, Youtube
Whoiscuriousgeorge, Youtube
Ishamayura Byrd, Twitter
Ishamayura Byrd, Twitter
Sidsings000, Youtube
Sidsings000, Youtube
Guest1001, Youtube
Guest1001, Youtube
Anon, BBC Complaints Log
Anon, BBC Complaints Log
Gabrielle, Chortle.com
Gabrielle, Chortle.com
Tres Ryan, Twitter
Tres Ryan, Twitter
Neolab, Guardian.co.uk
Neolab, Guardian.co.uk
Visualiser1, Twitter
Visualiser1, Twitter
Pirate Crocodile, Twitter
Pirate Crocodile, Twitter
Zombie Hamster, Twitter
Zombie Hamster, Twitter
Guest, Dontstartmeoff.com
Guest, Dontstartmeoff.com
Borathigh5, Youtube
Borathigh5, Youtube
World Without End, Twitter
World Without End, Twitter
Richard Herring, Comedian
Richard Herring, Comedian
Sam Rooney, Youtube
Sam Rooney, Youtube
Peter Ould, Twitter
Peter Ould, Twitter
Lancethrustworthy, Youtube
Lancethrustworthy, Youtube
Meninblack, Twitter
Meninblack, Twitter
Pudabaya, beexcellenttoeachother.com
Pudabaya, beexcellenttoeachother.com
Carla, St Albans, Dailymail.co.uk
Carla, St Albans, Dailymail.co.uk
12dgdgdgdgdgdg, Youtube
12dgdgdgdgdgdg, Youtube
Fowkes81, Twitter
Fowkes81, Twitter
Mini-x2, readytogo.net
Mini-x2, readytogo.net
NevW47479, UKTV.co.uk
NevW47479, UKTV.co.uk
Peter Fears, Twitter
Peter Fears, Twitter
Cabluigi, Guardian.co.uk
Cabluigi, Guardian.co.uk
Lenny Darksphere, Twitter
Lenny Darksphere, Twitter
Shit Crit, Twitter
Shit Crit, Twitter
Joskins, Leeds Music Forum
Joskins, Leeds Music Forum
Deepbass, Guardian.co.uk
Deepbass, Guardian.co.uk
Iain, eatenbymissionaries
Iain, eatenbymissionaries
Pudabaya, Twitter
Pudabaya, Twitter
Funday’schild, youtube.
Funday’schild, youtube.
Anonymous, don'tstartmeoff.com
Anonymous, don'tstartmeoff.com
BBC iPlayer edition of discussion of Stewart Lee on A Good Read
BBC iPlayer edition of discussion of Stewart Lee on A Good Read
Peter Ould, Youtube
Peter Ould, Youtube
Alwyn, Digiguide.tv
Alwyn, Digiguide.tv
Dominic Cavendish, Telegraph
Dominic Cavendish, Telegraph
Henry Howard Fun, Twitter
Henry Howard Fun, Twitter
Z-factor, Twitter.
Z-factor, Twitter.
Microcuts 22, Twitter
Microcuts 22, Twitter
Secretdeveloper, Youtube
Secretdeveloper, Youtube
Jamespearse, Twitter
Jamespearse, Twitter
Wharto15, Twitter
Wharto15, Twitter
Len Firewood, Twitter
Len Firewood, Twitter
Aiden Hearn, Twitter
Aiden Hearn, Twitter
Dave Wilson, Chortle.com
Dave Wilson, Chortle.com
Fairy Pingu, Twitter
Fairy Pingu, Twitter
Hiewy, Youtube
Hiewy, Youtube
Clampdown59, Twitter.
Clampdown59, Twitter.
Sweeping Curves, Twitter
Sweeping Curves, Twitter
Idrie, Youtube
Idrie, Youtube
Frankie Boyle, Comedian
Frankie Boyle, Comedian
Liam Travitt, Twitter
Liam Travitt, Twitter
Tweeterkiryakou, Twitter
Tweeterkiryakou, Twitter
Anon, westhamonline.com
Anon, westhamonline.com
Maninabananasuit, Guardian.co.uk
Maninabananasuit, Guardian.co.uk
Horatio Melvin, Twitter
Horatio Melvin, Twitter
General Lurko 36, Guardian.co.uk
General Lurko 36, Guardian.co.uk
Dominic Cavendish, Daily Telegraph
Dominic Cavendish, Daily Telegraph
Tokyofist, Youtube
Tokyofist, Youtube
Anamatronix, Youtube
Anamatronix, Youtube
98rosjon, Twitter
98rosjon, Twitter
Kozzy06, Youtube
Kozzy06, Youtube
Keilloh, Twitter
Keilloh, Twitter
Meanstreetelite, Peoplesrepublicofcork
Meanstreetelite, Peoplesrepublicofcork
Mrdavisn01, Twitter
Mrdavisn01, Twitter
Coxy, Dontstartmeoff.com
Coxy, Dontstartmeoff.com
Cyberbloke, Twitter
Cyberbloke, Twitter
GRTak, finalgear.com
GRTak, finalgear.com
Bobby Bhoy, Twitter
Bobby Bhoy, Twitter
Danazawa, Youtube
Danazawa, Youtube
Stokeylitfest, Twitter
Stokeylitfest, Twitter
Spanner, dontstartmeoff.com
Spanner, dontstartmeoff.com
Bosco239, youtube
Bosco239, youtube
Mpf1947, Youtube
Mpf1947, Youtube
Cojones2, Guardian.co.uk
Cojones2, Guardian.co.uk
Esme Folley, Actress, cellist, Twitter
Esme Folley, Actress, cellist, Twitter
Johnny Kitkat, dontstartmeoff.com
Johnny Kitkat, dontstartmeoff.com
Dahoum, Guardian.co.uk
Dahoum, Guardian.co.uk
Anon, dontstartmeoff.com
Anon, dontstartmeoff.com
FBC, finalgear.com
FBC, finalgear.com